真相集中营

The Guardian - China-Ping Pong review cheerful far-fetched caper that dives into Londons 1980s Chinatown

February 7, 2024   3 min   545 words

《卫报》对《乒乓》的评论称其为“欢乐而不切实际的深入伦敦80年代唐人街的搞笑故事”,这一评价颇具讽刺意味。虽然影片试图以一种轻松的方式探讨英国华人社区面对的种族主义问题,但评价者认为它的节奏略显软化,缺乏一些活力。影片以迷你长片的形式展现了一个关于中国餐馆业主家族的遗产纠纷,但情节过于荒诞,几乎有点不切实际。主角Elaine作为一个英国出生的华裔,不仅要处理家族的遗产问题,还要在中英文化之间左右为难,这种身份认同的挣扎也让观众颇感共鸣。然而,影片对于80年代伦敦唐人街和苏活的描绘值得一提,以及对话中蕴含的幽默元素也给人留下了深刻印象。总的来说,《乒乓》虽然在情节和节奏上有些不足,但其对于种族认同和文化交融的探讨还是值得肯定的。

There’s a sweet charm to Leong Po Chih’s 1986 mystery-comedy Ping Pong, set in and around the restaurant businesses of London’s Chinatown, now rereleased. It was produced by Film Four, who two years later brought out Mike Newell’s comparably set Soursweet, based on the Timothy Mo novel, although that is more serious. Ping Pong is eminently likable, though for me there is something perhaps a little soft-edged and carefully paced which dampens the energy a bit. It is a cheerfully far-fetched caper that could have taken some influence from the Alistair Sim classic Laughter in Paradise, and there’s sharp comment on the racism and enforced invisibility for Chinese communities in Britain, then as now.

Lucy Sheen made her acting debut here as Elaine, a law student who is tasked by the family of Mr Wong, a recently deceased Chinatown restaurateur, with handling his will, which has many eccentric provisions almost designed to promote arguments but also self-examination among the beneficiaries. He divides his restaurant and various assets among the grownup children, in-laws and friends on condition that they continue to run everything in the proper, traditional Chinese way, and that they refrain from their various vices of drinking and gambling. Elaine realises that it might somehow be her job to enforce these strictures. Worryingly, he has also provided for a mysterious Englishwoman called Sarah Lee, whom no one knows anything about but with whom Mr Wong may have had a secret relationship.

Most dismayingly, he wants his body to be returned to his home village in China, which will require a relative to accompany the coffin on the plane, and the family members must decide among themselves who this is to be. David Yip plays eldest son Mike, a heartless businessman who wants to build a seven-storey modern establishment on the site of his dad’s old place. Ric Young is younger brother Alan, a businessman married to an Englishwoman; Robert Lee is Wong’s old friend Mr Chen, an anglophile and Arsenal supporter who never had Wong’s success. As for Elaine, desperately trying to get these people to sign the relevant papers, she feels knocked back and forth between them like a ping pong ball, and knocked back and forth between Chinese and British identities in the same way.

There’s some interesting scenes of Chinatown and Soho from the 1980s, particularly its secret rooftop world, over which today’s members’ clubs now have views. And there are some nice dialogue exchanges: “When did you last see your father?” – “When did you last see your dentist?” A haughty government official patronisingly asks Elaine where she learned such excellent English: “The same place you did,” replies Elaine politely – ie, she was born in the UK. The film’s wayward whimsy carries it along.

skip past newsletter promotion

after newsletter promotion